Creamy Coleslaw with Carrots

My neighbor Linda brought this coleslaw to a July cookout, and I watched people go back for thirds while their pulled pork sat untouched. I asked for the recipe thinking it would be complicated, but she laughed and handed me a crumpled note—just cabbage, carrots, and a dressing she'd perfected over years of backyard gatherings. That afternoon, I realized the best dishes aren't fancy; they're the ones that make you feel taken care of.

I made a double batch for my son's graduation picnic, expecting it to be a side dish nobody would notice. Instead, people started asking me about it before they even tried the burgers. One of his teachers came back to the cooler three times, and I realized this humble coleslaw had somehow become the thing everyone remembered about that day.

Ingredients

• Green cabbage: This is your foundation—about 4 cups shredded. Buy it firm and fresh; a limp head of cabbage will make lifeless slaw.
• Red cabbage: Strictly optional, but it gives you those jewel-toned flecks that make people think you fussed. Use about 1 cup if you go for it.
• Carrots: Two large ones, grated. The sweetness they bring balances the vinegar in ways people can't quite identify but absolutely taste.
• Green onions: Thinly sliced—they add a whisper of sharpness that keeps things interesting.
• Mayonnaise: Use 2/3 cup of the real stuff. This is not the place to skimp or use a substitute that sounds healthier.
• Sour cream: Two tablespoons keeps it from being pure mayo-heavy; it adds a subtle tang that brightens everything.
• Apple cider vinegar: One tablespoon, measured properly. Too much makes it sour; too little and it tastes flat.
• Dijon mustard: Two teaspoons for subtle sophistication—not the bright yellow kind, the grainy brown one.
• Honey or sugar: A tablespoon rounds out the flavors and tells your tongue this is meant to be friendly, not sharp.
• Celery seed: Just 1/2 teaspoon, but don't skip it. This is the secret ingredient people notice without knowing what it is.
• Salt and pepper: Taste and adjust. Trust your palate more than measurements here.

Instructions

Shred and slice your vegetables:

Use a box grater for the carrots—it's faster than a knife and keeps them consistent. For the cabbage, a sharp chef's knife works beautifully if you take your time, or a food processor if you want to speed through it.

Combine everything raw:

Toss the cabbage, red cabbage if using, carrots, and green onions into a large bowl. At this stage, it looks almost too simple, but you're building the canvas for what comes next.

Make your dressing:

In a separate small bowl, whisk the mayo, sour cream, vinegar, mustard, honey, and celery seed until it's smooth and emulsified. This takes maybe a minute—you're looking for something that coats the back of a spoon.

Bring it all together:

Pour that creamy dressing over the vegetables and toss like you mean it. You want every strand of cabbage kissed with dressing, not just the bottom layer clinging to mayo.

Taste and season:

Pinch of salt, crack of pepper—taste it first before you add more. This is where the recipe becomes yours.

Let it sit and marry:

Cover the bowl and refrigerate for at least 30 minutes. The vegetables soften slightly, the flavors deepen, and what seemed sharp becomes mellow and balanced.

Pin it

There's a moment, right after you dress the coleslaw and before the refrigerator works its magic, where it just tastes like creamy vegetable salad. Then you taste it the next day, and suddenly it's something entirely different—balanced, alive, somehow more like itself. That transformation reminded me that patience in the kitchen isn't about being slow; it's about letting ingredients become what they're meant to be.

What Makes This Different from Store-Bought

Bagged coleslaw has this watery, acidic bite that feels like a punishment for convenience. This one tastes like someone made it because they wanted to, not because they had to. The mayo is creamy without being heavy, the vegetables stay crisp, and the dressing clings to each piece instead of pooling at the bottom. You notice the difference immediately, and so will everyone eating it.

When to Make This and What to Serve It With

This coleslaw lives for warm-weather gatherings—barbecues, picnics, cookouts where you're eating outside and everything tastes better. It pairs beautifully with pulled pork, grilled chicken, or even fish tacos. I've also served it on sandwiches as a textural contrast, and it makes them infinitely better. It's the kind of side dish that secretly steals the show because nobody expected something this simple to be this good.

How to Make It Your Own

Once you understand the ratio—creamy dressing, crisp vegetables, a balance of sweet and tangy—you can play around. Some people add a handful of chopped fresh parsley or dill for extra brightness. Others swap Greek yogurt for half the mayo if they want it lighter. I've even added a tablespoon of whole grain mustard instead of Dijon when I wanted more texture. The beauty of this recipe is that it's forgiving as long as you keep the bones intact.

• If you're making it for a crowd, the dressing doubles easily and everything else scales proportionally.
• Don't dress it too far ahead, or the vegetables will release water and dilute the whole thing.
• Taste it cold, straight from the fridge—that's how most people will eat it anyway.

Pin it

This coleslaw has become one of those recipes I make without thinking anymore, the way you might hum a song you've heard a thousand times. It's honest food that makes people happy, and that's really all any recipe needs to be.

Recipe FAQ

→ What vegetables are used in this coleslaw?

Green cabbage, red cabbage (optional), grated carrots, and thinly sliced green onions form the fresh vegetable base.

→ How is the creamy dressing made?

mayonnaise and sour cream are whisked together with apple cider vinegar, Dijon mustard, honey, celery seed, salt, and pepper for a tangy-sweet balance.

→ Can this dish be prepared ahead of time?

Yes, refrigerate for at least 30 minutes before serving to let flavors meld and enhance the taste.

→ Are there alternatives to mayonnaise in the dressing?

For a lighter version, substitute half the mayonnaise with Greek yogurt.

→ How long does the coleslaw keep in the refrigerator?

It stays fresh for up to 2 days when properly stored in the refrigerator.